Why mattress feel changes your neck position
When you sleep on your side, your shoulder sinks into the mattress. How far it sinks sets the gap between the mattress and your head, and your pillow fills that gap. A firmer surface lets the shoulder sink less, so the gap is larger and a taller pillow is usually needed. A softer surface lets the shoulder sink deeper, so the gap shrinks and a lower pillow tends to fit. Back and stomach sleepers have a smaller gap to fill, so their pillows are lower. For more on this, read Does Mattress Firmness Affect Pillow Height?
A mattress topper works the same way. A soft topper on a firm mattress can let your shoulder sink deeper than before, which may change the pillow height that feels right. Check your pillow again after you add or remove a topper.
What our fittings show
Our fitting data groups mattresses as soft or medium. There is no separate medium firm group, so the medium figures below are a close reference, not an exact match. Based on 300+ fittings (319 fittings, June 19 to October 30, 2026):
| Sleep position | Mattress | Fittings | Median pillow height |
|---|---|---|---|
| Side | Medium | 184 | about 4.9 inches |
| Back | Medium | 30 | about 4.1 inches |
| Stomach | Medium | 23 | about 3.7 inches |
| Side | Soft | 21 | about 4.5 inches |
Side sleepers on a soft mattress get a median about 0.4 inches lower than on a medium mattress, because the shoulder sinks deeper. The soft group is small, so treat it as a pattern and not a rule.
A quick check at home
Lie on your side with your usual pillow. Ask someone to take a photo from behind at head level. If your head tilts toward the mattress or away from it, the height is probably off. How to Tell If Your Pillow Is Too High walks through the signs. If you sleep on your side, Best Mattress for Side Sleepers covers what to look for in a surface.
What this means for your pillow
YOUP pillows range from about 3.1 to 5.7 inches in height, and every fitting lands within that range. On a medium mattress, side sleepers usually land in the upper part of that range, and 72% of them get about 4.9 inches or higher. Back and stomach sleepers land lower. Shoulder width also matters. Among side sleepers, the median height rises from about 4.1 inches below 15.0 inches of shoulder width to about 5.3 inches above 18.1 inches. If a topper changes how your mattress feels, fit again. See Pillow height: what a number can and cannot tell you, or look at the YOUP pillow.